• Heritage cities and destruction | Vol.1    Heritage cities and destruction | Vol.1    Heritage cities and destruction | Vol.1
  • Heritage cities and destruction | Vol.1    Heritage cities and destruction | Vol.1    Heritage cities and destruction | Vol.1
Table of
Contents
exit

Essay by images   |   Edited by Luca Cardani (Politecnico di Milano), Federica Causarano (IUAV Università di Venezia), Francesca Giudetti (Politecnico di Milano), Luciana Macaluso (Università degli Studi di Palermo) and Martina Meulli (Sapienza Università di Roma)

Destruction into fragmentsThoughts collected by means of images

accidental

creative act

loss

ruin

voluntary



These traces give us a present hold on the past and the future, as unmoving, unmixed things do not. [...] Effervescent or glacial, everything changes. Life is growth and decline, transformation and elimination. We might learn to take pleasure in that to maintain our continuity.


Kevin Lynch. 1990. Wasting Away. San Francisco: Sierra Club Books, 201.

The protective wall of Leonardo Da Vinci's Last Supper erected during the bombing of World War II. In Ronza, Robi. 2002. Milan 1940-1955. Bombed and rebuilt. Milan: Comune di Milano, 64-65.

PROLOGUE


As in a continuous chain, each image in this new journal issue is figuratively linked to the following one, creating a dialogue and raising questions on the different facets of the destruction. Destruction and Construction stand for both the process and its result. However, if construction has a finality in the constructed form, destruction has no purpose and completes itself in the unfinished.


In this space and time between wholeness and fragmentation also lies the possibility of rediscovering the profound meaning of beauty or ‘the greatest pleasure’ of life as a fragment, paraphrasing the role of Thomas Bernard’s ‘Old Masters’. It is a beauty that resides in the narrative power of time, in the feeling of “the other”, in the curiosity of discovery, in the possibility of a horizon of meaning on which to be born again each time.


Snapshot of the loss (Milan, 1946), utopian city fragments (The New Babylon, 1969), imprints of book pages carried away by the flood (Florence, 1966), erased artistic memory (Artemisia Gentileschi painting, 1616-1618), chaos of formal beauty (Krasnojarsk, 2010), new perspectives for the contemporary city (Paris, 1975), unexpected wounds immediately sutured (Beirut, 2020). But also abandoned architecture as a symbol of lifeless power (L’Aquila, 2006), earthquakes theatricality (Naples, 1981),  destruction that breeds monsters (Francesco Hayez painting, 1867), and exploding collapsed bridge (Genoa, 2019) are here the ‘images of thought’ (Denkbilder) of the same narrative.

Milan Urban Census 1946 (made after the bombing and in preparation for the 1953 PRG): city planning sheet no. 174 (Piazza Vetra, Via Chiusa, Via Pioppette, Corso di Porta Ticinese, Via Pio IV). ©Comune di Milano

Constant Nieuwenhuys, Symbolic representation of The New Babylon, 1969. Collage of street maps on paper, 120x133.2 cm. ©Kunstmuseum Den Haag

Flood of November 4, 1966 at the Gabinetto G.P. Vieusseux, Florence. Photograph by Donato Costanza. By courtesy of the Gabinetto Scientifico Letterario G.P. Vieusseux.

Artemisia Gentileschi, Magdalene (mutilated composition), c. 1615-18, oil on canvas, 146.5x110 cm, Private collection.

Marjan Teeuwen, Destroyed House Krasnoyarsk 1, 2010. In Teeuwen, Marjan. 2017. Destroyed House. Amsterdam: Valiz, 146-147.

Gordon Matta-Clark, Conical Intersect, 1975. The photomontage is composed of two photographs taped together on the recto, 17,1x14,5cm (photomontage). Credits: Canadian Centre for Architecture, Gift of Estate of Gordon Matta-Clark. ©Estate of Gordon Matta-Clark/SODRAC

Carl Gerges, Traditional houses in Mar Mikhael, destroyed by the 4 August blast, 2020. ©Carl Gerges Architects

Emiliano Dante, “6 Aprile 2006, prefettura, poco dopo l'alba”. In Dante, Emiliano, Laurenzi, Massimiliano, Nanni, Valentina. 2009. Terremoto zeronove. Diari da un sisma. Also in the documentaries “Into the blue”, 2010, and “Appennino”, 2017. ©Emiliano Dante

Joseph Beuys performing “Terremoto in Palazzo” (Earthquake in Palace) at the Modern Art Agency Naples, 1981. ©Collezione Archivio Amelio-Santamaria

Francesco Hayez, La destrucción del Templo de Jerusalén, 1867. Canvas, 183x282 cm. Venice, Accademia di Belle Arti, gift from the author, 1868. By permission of the Ministry of Culture.

Marco Menghi, Morandi Bridge (Genoa), demolition, 28-06-2019. ©Marco Menghi

EPILOGUE

Wisława Szymborska, 1998. Poems new and collected 1957-1997. San Diego: Harvest Book Harcourt, 228-229. 

Altri saggi di Adh journal

vedi tutte
  • ADH journal
  • ADH journal